Critical Pigeon

opinions and analysis

Dark Souls 2 is a Bigger Adventure Than the Original.

This one design choice made Dark Souls 2 feel huge

A screenshot from the Dark Souls 2 Steam page.

It’s no secret that Dark Souls 2 isn’t for everyone. But I’m not the first and I’m sure I won’t be the last to say that it’s somewhat underrated. In fact, it’s my favourite entry in the trilogy.

But I almost quit after the first six hours.

I was completely at odds with the game. I hated it. Primarily for a reason that I believe is widely known; a statistic vaguely named Adaptability that tweaks the invincibility frames of the integral dodge roll mechanic.

Starting with less invincibility frames resulted in a frustration that I never experienced in the many hours I spent with the original game. It felt off, taking damage when it felt like I shouldn’t. The complete antithesis of the design of Dark Souls, a game that was tough but almost always fair.

Once I’d stuck a few levels in Adaptability, however, I was well on my way. The game opened up. I began to enjoy what makes Dark Souls 2 so great. The world. The characters. The atmosphere.

There are some other gripes that players tend to have with Dark Souls 2. The bosses, for one. Gimmicks often make the bosses of Dark Souls 2 more like set-pieces and less like dramatic one-on-ones. There are also a variety of ambushes dotted around the world that can bring a quick and frustrating end to your adventures.

If you can get past it, though, Dark Souls 2 offers an experience that, for my money, is a bigger adventure than the original game.

Now, I should specify; by bigger, I don’t mean better. The original Dark Souls is a masterwork of interconnected locations replete with loops and shortcuts that tickle the brain in a very specific way. Dark Souls 2, however, takes a different approach.

Where Dark Souls provides rambling routes that subtly blend and connect in unexpected ways, Dark Souls 2 cuts out big, bold chunks of world with their own immediately recognisable and distinctive stamp.

From the calm coastal town of Majula, to the dimly-lit No-Man’s Wharf and the magnificent stones of Heide’s Tower of Flame, all the way to the poison-green Black Gulch and the towering metallic fortress that makes up the Iron Keep, Dark Souls 2’s locations feature such distinctive visuals that they’re often incredibly memorable.

That’s not to say every location in Dark Souls 2 is a masterpiece. It’s got its fair share of misfires. The aforementioned Black Gulch is just as bad as the original game’s Blighttown. And it’s not like the first Dark Souls game didn’t feature unique zones.

But the separate and sudden changes of each zone in Dark Souls 2 makes the adventure more obvious.

The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring is one of my favourite films for many reasons. One of which is relevant here; it provides an unforgettable trek from cosy countryside, to the picturesque home of the elves, across mountains and into a dangerous mine, a quick detour through a beautiful woodland, before finally reaching a dramatic climax at a riverside forest.

The trek is so unforgettable because it has very clear chapters. The Shire is a safe and warm countryside. Bree is a dark and rainy town, and the people are much less friendly. Both already have such clear aesthetics. There’s no question when the hobbits reach Bree that it’s not the same as the Shire. Rivendell is equally different with its lavish architecture and fusion with nature. 

I could go on, but the point is: Dark Souls 2 takes the Fellowship approach.

This, to me, is what fantasy really is. These massive leaps from one extreme to the next all heaped into the same bucket of a continent is what makes Middle Earth, to me, so enrapturing. It’s what makes me feel like I’m on a proper grand adventure, and not just a really, really long hike.

What’s more, it cranks up the excitement of finding a new location. The visuals, the new enemies, the music, even the lore. Each location in Dark Souls 2 is its own self-contained playground. At least, when they’re at their best.

This works for one reason.

In the grand and ambitious leap from Dark Souls to Dark Souls 2, one key decision was made. One final nail in the fate of its design and the eventual design of Dark Souls 3.

Dark Souls 2 features fast travel from the get-go.

And I don’t even like fast travel systems. I use them. I use them because it’s hard not to optimise the fun out of a game.

But I don’t like them. They allow me to miss out on the adventure. Take Skyrim, for instance. Travelling from one place to another without fast travel can be great fun, especially early on, when there’s so much to see and so much to do. But I still use the fast travel because it’s convenient.

The fast travel in Dark Souls 2 isn’t entirely different. The world no longer feels interconnected when you can jump freely between bonfires, an issue that the first game also suffered once players finally gained access to the feature.

But here, in Dark Souls 2, it works. It works because the locations are already so separate. The design of the world takes the fast travel into account and simply does away with the immersion of the original game’s interconnectivity.

And players will be doing plenty of fast travel, anyway, since they’ll want to repeatedly head back to the game’s hub — the aforementioned Majula.

Perhaps this is why fans are so divided when it comes to Dark Souls 2. It is, after all its tweaks, still a Dark Souls game. It still, by and large, follows the formula. But in its grand ambitions it could be argued that it lost what made the original Dark Souls so great.

And instead it became a different beast entirely. One that challenges in different ways, offers adventure through different means, and bares its world bluntly and fully.

Check out Dark Souls 2 on Steam!